Second Game of Christmas

The First Game of Christmas: Alternity

Now we reach the second game of Christmas, and boy oh boy is it a treat! This was the single most influential roleplaying game in my life. I can honestly say that without it I would not be the same person I am today. It is based off of a film trilogy so iconic everyone recognizes it instantly. The prequel came later and no one liked it as much. And now finally, as of last year a new movie came out that may not be as good as the original but it hit all the right notes and had an interesting Father Son dynamic to it. And this series is...Tremors!

HAHAHAHA! No I am just kidding. Its Star Wars. The game is Star Wars. Come to think of it, though, why isn't there a Tremors RPG. It would be awesome.

STAR WARS!!!!!!!!! YEAH!!!!!

For this review I will be digging into the Star Wars Roleplaying Game by West End Games. There were two editions, though the second one had two versions. I will be digging into my favorite version which is Second Edition Revised and Expanded. A brief note on the earlier versions. First edition is excellent, though more hand-wavy and free from than second edition. Second edition(not revised and expanded) is not very good, just in layout and explanations on how things work.



Funny story, this was the first game I ever played. I had technically made characters for Palladium games and AD&D 2nd edition but this game is the one I played first, and it was the game I first GMed, as my friends refused to run a game for me. To this day my GMing style is based a lot on what I learned from the GM's section of these books.

Peritextual Elements
Revised and Expanded really set the bar for me on how a game should be laid out, and how it should look and feel. All color high gloss pages with quality art and easy to read sidebars. It also had these advertisements in it for various in universe things, like an Imperial recruitment poster, or a Rebel Propaganda poster, or an advertisement for a tourist cruise, or wanted posters for the rebels from the movies. It was so very nice. Also the way it did sidebars was through various in universe character explaining things to you. And each had a head shot of that character with an expression ad all that. It allowed for the rules and setting to be clear and well explained while also allowing for character and mood to come across without getting in the way. I loved that. Its one of the things that drew me to the Dresden Files game as well. Such afun thing.

Mechanics
The game's core mechanic is a dice pool of six sided dice that are rolled and added together. You have a set of attributes with specific skills attached to them. You usually start with an attribute between 2 and 4 and skill ratings of 0 to 3. When you do a task you add the skill to the attribute roll that many dice and add up all the numbers to beat a target number, One of those dice is the wild die, which must be visually distinct. If it rolls a six the wild die explodes and you can roll it again and add both the six and the next roll to the die roll. This goes on as long as you keep rolling sixes. If it rolls a one you remove the highest die roll from the roll. Some people hate the wild die, but I dig it. You also have character points and Force Points which allow you to do interesting things with dice. Force Points can be spent to double a dice pool for a given roll, but you only get them back when you are heroic, lightside, and paragon. Character points are probably the only mechanical widget in the game I have an issue with. They can be used, on a one for one basis, to add dice to a roll. That sounds awesome right? Well, the issue is that they are also your XP and if you spend them on a roll, you cannot spend them later to advance. This leads to point hoarding and death spirals, so I don't care for that as much as the rest of the mechanics. Also two small issues are strength as resistance to damage and fore powers.

When you get hit you roll you strength plus you armor versus the damage roll. If you get high enough you take no damage. This led to odd situations where wookies were unable to be damaged by anything. There are a few fixes for that out there, but it is an issue to look out for, The other issue is Force Powers. They were a bit complicated, started out really weak and ended up completely OP, as they had no dice limit on their skills. That meant that eventually you could get impossible skill levels and just dominate every scene. Also this game introduced Darkside Points, which you gained by being evil, a jerk, and very renegade. If you got enough Darkside Points you lost control of your character and the character became a GM character and a villain. So watch it with the force lightning. Funny story I have a couple of friends of mine who claim that they can only play Jedi in this game if they are drunk. If they are sober the rules make no sense to them. Not sure if that's true, but the rules can get a little messy. I am a super fan of the system, though. I mean, I love it so much I started a project using this system(modified) and I think that it might even be going somewhere interesting.

Setting
Um, have you seen the movies? Of course you have. Everyone has. Literally everyone, ever. The series is so powerful it travels in time! It is the reason cavemen painted on walls. Well maybe not that, but seriously, I don't think I need to explain why the setting is cool. That said, this game added so much to the setting. The had loads of expansion books and boxed sets that came out that expanded on the setting and tied into the movies and even dug into the comics and the few books that had come out. Seriously this game first came out at the dawn of the expanded universe(now called legacy, because J.J. Abrams hates me). It would go into detail and explain all sorts of cool stuff that was only briefly sown or hinted at in the movies. And the books statted out everything. Do you like Star Wars? Good then you will like the setting of this game. If you don't you won't.

That is it for today Game of Christmas. I hope you like it.

Next...

Mage

First Game Of Christmas

Alrighty folks it is coming up on Christmas and this year I am going to count down the days until Christmas with a list of my top twelve favorite role playing games of all time. Now favorite is pretty subjective and I picked these games for a number of reasons; how much I have played it, how influential it has been on me, and my emotional connection to the game are all things that went into the hat for my favorite games of all time. So without further ado lets start the list with...

Number 1: Alternity

This game will always be of immense importance to me. It was the first game I owned that consistently drew me back to it over and over. The mechanics, the settings, and the art all drew me in and held me there. I think it has some flaws and all, but it hit so many of the things I was looking for that it was easy to get past the small number of minor annoyances.

The Peritextual Elements

The art is just fantastic in the game. The main books have some truly spectacular art and the rest of the book series have, at worst, adequate art. The pages are a semi gloss and a pretty heavy weight. The hard covers are solidly built and sturdy. I have had the Player's and Game Master's Handbooks since 1998, I have taken them around the world and through a war and the cover is still solidly held together. Now I try not to hurt my books, but even still that is a fine quality book cover. The only real downside I have on the layout is the dark blue green they use for sidebars, they can get a little rough on the eyes, but it is a minor gripe.

Mechanical Elements

The core mechanic is pretty interesting. Roll a twenty sided die and try and get below your skill level(or half your attribute level for untrained skills). However it is more than ust a binary pass fail system. Each skill roll is broken into four possible outcomes: Failure, ordinary success, Good Success, and amazing success. the lower you roll the better your result. The die roll can be altered by a situational modifier which is a a die that is rolled alongside the d20 and either subtracted or added depending on game factors. The game is heavily task oriented and has a large number of skills. There are broad skills which cannot be advanced, but give a solid basis for doing all sorts of things and specialty skills which allow you to increase them with experience points. This is a bit of a detriment as the game carries some issues relating to how the attributes work. you get skill points based off of intelligence and so you can have a variable number of skill points. With the large number of skills it can be very difficult to get the character you want to play. each specialty skill also has a series of rank specific advantages that allow you to do cool stuff with the skill if you have a high enough rank i the skill. I really like these and wish there were more.  Every now and again I look through the game and think about reworking it into something simpler and more unified.

The game also has Last resort points which let you modify rolls and the like, but as they cost experience points and are very limited by your attributes you will not likely see them in your game. You may also spend your skill points on perks and gain some skill points on flaws. However as you don't have enough skill points in general, most people never get more than one perk and only gather the least offensive flaws. There is the requisite big lists of weapons and equipment, I like it, but nothing special. And there is a bunch of optional stuff like mutations, psionics, and cybernetics. The GMs guide also has rules for FX, which include super powers(which do not work very well at all in this system), spells, and miracles. Also conversion rules for AD&D 2nd ed, so you can now play your space elves.

Settings

Stardrive was the first big setting for the game and it has a boatload of setting material for it. It is set in the Verge, an area that was the very edge of human space before the second galactic war. During the war they were left to there own devices, but now the war is over and everyone is trying retake their old holdings and things are getting crazy what with alien invasions and stuff. The setting is a really solid kitchen sink space opera and it has one of my favorite campaign plot devices ever. the lighthouse is a massive space station/war ship that does a constant circuit through the verge. It is like Babylon five, but bigger and it travels. So it lets the players have a home base and be involved in all sorts of places.

The other major setting is Dark Matter. Which is one of the best settings for nineties style strange investigations into the unknown. You play members of the Hoffman institute who are investigating all the strange goings on. See, there is this stuff called dark matter that ebbs and flow through the universe like a tide. When the dark tide is high, magic, psionics, aliens, and dimensional travelers become common. And the tide is rising. If you ever wanted to fight a nanotech hive that has taken a human host one week and a greater demon wielding mystic flame the next, boy howdy is this the game for you. Also it reworks the magic and miracles FX rules from the GMs guide and they are some of my favorite magic systems in gaming ever. Super fun setting.

There was also a take on Gamma World for the system, but it only had one small book, and was middling at best. Finally there was a Starcraft quickstart that came out right before the gameline was cancelled. It is not that good, but I do wish they had made a whole game book for it rather than just a sample adventure and a bunch of generic pregens.


So that is the first game of Christmas. Tomorrow...

Star Wars(You know which one)

Challenge of the Star Knights: Delta Academy Beginings

Once their were a thousand schools for training the Star Knights. Eager students, the best in the galaxy, entered those hallowed halls of learning. Each was a beacon of hope and learning. During the war many schools fell to the forces of the Maggedon. Others were abandoned or hidden, lost to the sweep of ages. Now all that remain are fifteen, each hidden away through unity technology and remote locations. Delta academy is hidden away in the Marconi Traverse, on the very periphery of he civilized galaxy. While the Star Knight Academies still accept only the best of the best the politics and petty grievances still crop up. Delta Academy is where they send those students and teachers who are too much of a problem for the more prestigious academies.

If you want to read previous posts before digging into this one:
The Pitch
Rules Part 1
Rules Part 2
Ikhai
Species

Now your caught up. Lets get started on the problem at hand.

A big part of any school setting is the teachers and the headmaster(call them what you will) as well as the ancillary characters in and around the school. When setting out to make characters it is important to showcase and highlight these characters. They will be expositions characters primarily, though they can add more to the game than that. I would like to see them as sometimes adventure hooks, and complications, as well as being quest givers and those who explain. I was having a real rough go of it trying to sort out how I could make them work and make the players care about them.

I had a bit of a breakthrough with the school setup. I want there to be a bunch of teachers and for those teachers to have a set of mechanical effects in game. I was reading through some of my other games and the answer presented itself. I think I will do something like Icons from 13th Age but tweaked to fit this setting and fit the tropes I am aiming for.

When starting a new campaign/game the players will look over the list of teacher/mentor archetypes and get to set some relationships with them. Those relationships will be positive, negative, or conflicted. And they will be rated from one to three dice. I do not think they will have to have relationships with all the mentors/teachers, but they should each have relationships with two to three so that way you can get a solid idea of what each player is looking for in play and who they care about.

Those dice maybe used in game to gain social advantage, or a moral boost to a roll(through memory of encouragement or some such). How this works is this. When you are in a situation where you are acting either in accordance with the wishes of your mentor(for a positive relationship) or against the wishes of your mentor(for negative) you may roll the dice against a set difficulty. If you succeed you may use your relationship dice as an add on to your roll, or to gain access to something you might not have gained otherwise(I am still working on this and so it is less clear right now). If you fail the roll you may choose to still use the dice, but your relationship dice will decrease by one. Conflicted relationships could be used in either case, but the ramifications will be different depending on how you use them.

Right now this is just the very basics of the idea, so expect it to change as I try it out in playtesting. I would love to hear any thoughts on these mechanics as I am not entirely sure that this is the correct mechanical path to suit my game.

The Current List of Mentor Archetypes
The Uncaring Stickler
The Schemer
The Kindly Mentor
The Gentle Meddler
The Mother Figure
The Father Figure
The Chaotic Mess
The Social Climber
The Washed Up Master

I will probably add more and make alterations to these archetypes as I go.

I would also like to work out a method for building a relationship web so that the the players and GM would have a method of easily seeing possible ramifications for actions. I have thought about using the method in the Smallville RPG, or maybe something else...I am not really sure on that one if it is even needed. Other things I am working on in the setting are Orders, which are like houses in Harry Potter, groups you are all in together to bind you and give you rivals. I am still working out the details of those as I don't think a sorting hat type situation would sit all that well with some players. My current idea is that students are assigned to orders at random and the players are all just part of the same order, but I am not sure that would be all that great either. I need a way to get people to agree on an order while still allowing for all sorts of personality types and problem solving methodologies. I want to avoid pigeonholing people into certain types of behavior within given orders, but I also want the orders to feel unique and have personality.

It is an issue. I will probably do a whole post on it as I keep going round and round on it and can't seem to make it fit. So that is it for now. I had a decent idea(I think) and I think I am aiming in the right direction. Let me know what you think.

World Building Part 8: Demons and Monsters

At the dawn of time something went wrong. No one knows exactly when, as it was before the first people came forth onto the world. However into the perfect creation came a flaw. A being of great power that was the antithesis of the world spirit, the anti element if you will. It sought to wipe out everything and bring about and eternal nothing. This was Niddhoggandr, the demon king. Long ago it was sealed away with great elder magics, no long lost, by the four chosen disciples of the four peoples. All demons that exist today are but pale shadows of the true demon awaiting it's eventual release.

What no one realizes, is that event caused untold destruction  in the Fallen, a parallel and similar dimension, and directly led to the constant threat of demons. The demons seek to either destroy that original spell and hopefully save their world, or gather as much life energy as they can to prolong the life of their world. to gather that energy they must cause hardship, pain, and despair among the peoples of this world. To break the spell would reawaken Niddhoggandr and spell doom for this world.

Alrighty folks I am back to playing around with this bit of world building. I am still working on my other projects, don't you worry, but I had a bit of inspiration on how demons and such would work in this world and so I thought I would share. It has come to the point where I will need to come up with a name for the world. As I have been building the setting I have seen a few things start to pop up, the ideas of harmony and balance are pretty key to the setting, extremes of one thing or another seem to be bad, in the setting as it currently exists. That is what led to humanity conquering the other peoples, so I could go forward with that. So I need a word that sounds like a planet name that also means something like harmony. So I got to digging in good old google translate and came up with, Amoni ,the Haitian Creole word for harmony. I chose it because it sounds nice and is easy to say and spell. I may change it in the future but I am currently leaning toward calling the world I am building Amoni. Yay!

Previous Posts in the series:
Part 1 Initial Ideas
Part 2 Airships
Part 3 Peoples
Part 4 Basic Magic
Part 5 History
Part 6 Deeper Magic
Part 7 Culture

On to the world building:

There are two alternate dimensions that seem to directly interact with Amoni in some way. The Far Away and The Fallen. Each contains beings that seek to access Amoni and the people therein. These beings are known as demons and spirits and they seem to delight in chaos and the destruction of the world for their own purposes.

The Fallen may once have been like the world, but something went wrong and the energies of the dimension became corrosive and corrupting. Most demons hail from this land, sent to reap the life energies of the world and return them to the wastes to use that energy to prolong the life of that dimension. People can access and use the energies of The Fallen, though there is a cost. People who tap into this dimension's energy can gain great power and the ability to do what would normally be impossible standard magics. However as they use it they become corrupted and eventually become demons themselves, unable to survive in the world naturally without harvesting life energy merely to survive.This is the nature of what folks call the undead, people who have become so corrupted that they must devour life energy to survive.

The Far Away is a strange land of pure spirit and natural energy energy. It is wild and full of dangers.The landscape constantly shifts to suit the moods of the spirits who reside within it. Often they will seek to echo the world's landscapes, but they will feel off and have odd angles.  Time has no meaning and the beings who dwell there wish to steal your soul and ride your body in the world. They live in a world without meaning or feeling, and so possessing a person and wandering about in Amoni is a great vacation for them. Make no deals with the spirits from the Far Away. For every deal you make brings you closer to falling under their power.The Spirits behave like spoiled brats who have never had anyone tell them no. Even when they wish to do good, they cause chaos and disorder.some spirits are actually fully malevolent, and these are also called demons.

Those are my first thoughts on the demons and spirits that inhabit the land as well as a brief on the worlds they come from. Now I want to dig into creatures and monsters of the world. I am currently trying to sort out exactly what makes a good creature description and which creatures do not need a description. I could go the route of Jack Vance where I just give the creatures a name and do not describe them in any detail. This works very well in the Dying Earth and might work here. I do feel like I would be missing out on some fun though. I could also go full on Audubon and give a detailed description of every creature in the world with detailed analyses of the habits and variants of the species, but man that seems like a lot of work.

Perhaps if I knew for what I am going to do with this project that would help me. If I am making this just for my own fun and nothing else then I guess I can just do whatever animals and monsters interest me and be done with it. I can describe what I like as I like. However this is not just for me. I mean I am already posting online so at the very least this is for the entertainment of at least one other person(though I hope everyone who reads this is at least a little entertained...please?). Because of that I must have some sort of focus in what I design here. If I were designing a world to write fiction about then I could probably get away with the Vancian method of merely describing the barest of minimums, though all I would need then would be a list of weird sounding names and some basic descriptors on the size of the creature and if it would eat people. Then there is my wheelhouse, RPGs. If I am designing this for RPGs then I need to give the GMs enough information that they can use the creature in play and make the game more fun.   I would need to do one of three things with each creature(perhaps all three). The creature needs to add flavor, challenge, or plot to the setting. I think this final method would be most useful to me here. It is always easier to describe less than what I have in my notes and adding more is relatively easy(though it takes more time), but this final method will at least give me a set of goals to aim for. Lets break that down with some examples.

Welcome to flavor country. Animals described for flavor exist to define the world and showcase either its normalcy or its strangeness...or both. So when we describe a creature that is mundane and ordinary in the context of the world, something that does not add drama or danger we must use it for flavor(I think, though let me know if I am wrong). So for this setting I was thinking of not having horses be a thing in the world. I have already established that the Bit-Bit ride about in giant flamingos(not too giant as the bit bit aren't all that big themselves) so perhaps birds have taken the place of draft and riding animals. Though I think that lizards would be cool too. S I think I will brain storm a little on the riding and draft animals of Amoni:

Phoru: Humans ride about on terror birds, Mostly this is because I really like the idea of giant riding birds, but it also fits with the motif of the Human Empire, where even their mounts are dangerous and scary.

Djialisks: Njan have domesticate giant lizards that they ride. There are two types of domesticated Djialisk: The Wa-Geck is a giant gecko that hey can ride only with special harnesses and ride over any surface. The Annago - giant monitors, unruly and difficult, but super useful in war and for draft work(pulling large wagons and plowing). Cats riding lizards just sounds like fun and it fits better with the desert terrain they dwell in.

Gelves: The great war flamingos of the Bit-Bit have already been discussed and so I will just say I really like the idea of tiny knights riding great pink flying death machines. But maybe that is just me.

Once you get past beasts for flavor you get into beasts as challenge. This is your standard monster or danger. It is the Bear that made its home in the abandoned farm or the dragon pillaging a town. The beast exists to be defeated, driven off, or appeased. though this is fairly simple, it is important to know what motivates the creature, its instincts and desires.

Sky Whales: Lumbering behemoths of the sky. While they are called whales they are in fact something else entirely. They fly through the inflation of air bladders that are then heated with elemental fire energy, allowing them to be neutrally buoyant in the sky. They then channel air energies to travel slowly through the clouds gathering sky plankton. They are dangerous to air travel as they see anything smaller than them as food and most things smaller than a full on warship are smaller. They are territorial, and fairly passive unless disturbed or hungry.

Shabu-Shabu: a swamp dwelling creature that feeds on blood. It is a small bipedal creature that appears somewhat like a Bit-Bit from a distance. It spreads disease and actively hunts intelligent peoples. The Bit-bit claim that it is a curse on their people by Niddhoggandr for locking it away.

Finally there are creatures as plot. these are more than just challenge but the goal of the story/adventure/narrative itself is so tied into the creature that it becomes the core of the story entirely. Examples from other stories include the Questing Beast, The Unicorn(who could heal anything), and The Dragon Fafnir(as the whole of the story is based around the horde of the dragon and the ring that was in the horde), also Smaug(though he is just a better characterized Fafnir when you get right down to it).

Lundorm: Massive worms that devour rock in the mountain ranges of the world. They cannot digest precious metals however and those form into an ultra dense melded precious metal sphere in their many stomachs. these spheres are the most valuable metals in the world as they accept enchantment better than any other material. As the Lundorms are too large to domesticate and too dangerous to live near there is a powerful market for the Spheres and a whole adventuring community has grown up around Lundorm Hunting.

Ur-Phoen: A massive bird lat lives far from civilization. It is said to be the first bird, somehow still alive after all these years. One of its feathers when properly treated can cure any disease, and it is said that eating its heart would grant immortality.

And that is my thoughts on demons and creatures in rough. I would love to hear your thoughts on the matter. Comments, critiques, and ideas are always welcome.I will probably do my next post on the Challenge of the Star Knights, and later this month I am going to start a big new thing, so look for that(#12gamesofchristmas ...shh). So I guess I am fairly busy in the upcoming weeks.

Challenge of the Star Knights: Ever Expanding Horizon

While working through the mechanical issues with the game(Part 1 and Part 2) I realized I needed to lay down a bit more on my thoughts on the setting ideas and possible issues and solutions. The initial pitch is solid, I think, but it does not lay out some of the core themes and ideas of the setting. So in this I will be laying out some of the details and maybe talking about the setting as a whole and the issues that cropped up when I sat down to do this post. 

With this game world I am aiming for a kind of classic space opera feel(though hopefully with enough plausibility to not break verisimilitude) so I wanted a bunch of alien species and faster than light travel to be fairly common. I also wanted a sort of operatic and epic feel to it, I have always been heavily influence by Jack Kirby's Fourth World and I love the visuals and ideas of the MCU's Asgard and Jupiter Ascending. So I wanted something with a feel of Mythic Significance and  also to be a coming of age story set in a school for Space Knights. I am not sure if that will be doable, but I am going to give it a go.

 Firstly lets get started on the various Sophonts of the setting. Now, I want there to be lots of them so I think I will just focus on the ones who are most important/influential in the setting. No here comes the difficult part. ready? In a game world when building characters you want to give the players enough information on the species/race/culture that they can understand it, but not so much that it gets bogged down with details. I have written on this topi before for a different project, if you want to see my thoughts there. However in this i want to look at the potential solutions and maybe analyze those(as much as I am capable of analyzing anything). Mostly in this I will be focusing on statements I have read elsewhere and seeing if they might be of use here.

 First I want to dig into a statement made in a post on the Walking Eye, specifically Lesson #3, "Complexity Should Emerge from Play, not Setting." I think that this is a fascinating insight and could be of use when working forward on this project. I also think the rest of the lessons in that series are quite interesting and could foster whole discussions of their own. The thing I like about this is the idea that clarity is important and that you should start with stark and simple designs. However the issue comes down to avoiding stereotyping and constraining player agency through setting design. However, stereotypes can be very useful to players when starting out as it gives everyone a solid starting point off of which they can riff and push against. I think there is a lot of interesting insight packed into this Lesson, I am not sure I completely agree with it, but that may be a knee-jerk reaction on my part as a world builder. Were I working on this for fiction or for some other purpose I would definitely want to have loads of nuance and such in my world, but this is for a game. One of my core beliefs is the idea that in games you should endeavor to make as much of the game as possible(all if you can) player facing(and yes to me the GM counts as a player).

On a similar note I have been digging into Dungeon World and Fellowship a bit. They are both fantastic games Powered By The Apocalypse.  they also both deal with similar ideas to the one presented above. In Dungeon World there is a principle of, " Draw Maps, Leave Blanks." Basically it is the idea that the game's setting should be a framework rather than a straitjacket. It should inform the players on the type of world they are in, while allowing for them to change things and add to it. I think the same idea could be applied to character species. Each Every statement of truth should be surrounded by blanks for the Players(GM included) to define as play goes forward. Blanks are questions to be answered. If you make a pacifist Klingon or a war like Vulcan you have added a deeper question to the nature of these species. Are Vulcan normally pacifistic or is a war like nature more likely than not? Are Klingon all pacifists or is this unusual? Each question adds a another truth to the universe and adds further questions. The best part is that you can leave those blank if they don't matter to the players, or you can delve as deeply as you like. this leads to a sense of ownership for the players and a sense of investment in the setting.

In Fellowship this idea is tied directly into the game mechanics, one of the player jobs is to tell stories about the chosen type and to define their people as the game goes on. You can start out with elves who are space aliens or elves who are fairy nobles. You can define the technology and magic as you go along, and the GM gets to define the Dark Lord and what that means to the setting. It is a really marvelous set of gaming principles. When I read through it I kind of want to steal it for every game I design. However it does depend on a series of stereotypes to work within or against. Everyone kind of has a similar idea of what elves are now(thanks to Tolkien and Jackson) and everyone has a similar idea on wizards, dwarfs, and so on. So once again we are back to starting with a very simple idea and allowing the players to build outward from their.

I am not sure if I have done proper analysis or critical thought on these ideas, so much as built a cumulative case that supports the direction I want to go. I am perfectly willing to be wrong on these thoughts, but for now I will work with the simple and we will see how this goes as I build further outward. 

The Current Dominant Species
One of the central conceits of the setting is that a long time ago there were three great species. I am currently calling those species the Elders, but I am not really solid on that as the term for them. These Elders fought a series of wars with the Maggedon, also and elder species. The Maggedon sought to wipe out all life in the universe and had the technology and numbers to do it. the three groups of Elders won the war but were wiped out in the process. Now lets expand on that a bit. the elders saw that they would not survive the war in any recognizable way, so they sought to create hidden enclaves of beings that were different enough from them as not to draw the attention of the Maggedon directly and yet similar enough so that something of the Elders would be passed on to the future. All of the sophonts who exist in the now of the setting are related to or responding to the meddling of the ancients. I think that is an interesting idea, like David Brin's uplift universe, but without the patronage of an elder species. So there is a lot more chaos and less stagnation. How people view the Elders is as varied as how they view anything else. There are those who have records dating back to the War and there are those who only have the barest hints of meddling in their past. So, with that said lets do a bit of species design!

Chashi: Short, squat, turtle like technicians and philosophers. Few become Star Knights as they view combat as wasteful and those who seek to become Star Knights are seen as the honorable insane. Though many do become technical and logistical officers in the Knight Support Corps. They claim to have been out in the galaxy the longest of the Younger Species. The were directly uplifted by the Elder Peoples before the fourth extinction war. Their histories hold much knowledge of the ways of the Elders, though much of it is in pseudo-mystical poetry and is open to interpretation.

Imdar: Hyperactive species of Soldiers, scholars, and scientists. One of the early species to gain access to the wider galaxy. They see themselves as the children of the elder races, as they were uplifted by them toward the end of the Fourth Extinction War though they have no records of that time. They maintain the Grand Archive, a collection of all archeological and scientific knowledge their species has ever recorded. Many in the wider galactic society believe them to a divergent sub species of the Humani, due to some similar genetic markers.

Glass Walkers: Energy Beings, seeded among the Nuetron Stars by the elders. They live a listless life of purposeless existence. They have few needs and impressive intellects. Many become bored with a life of deep thought and seek danger and adventure in the wider galaxy. While incredibly passionate they tend to see nothing as mattering to any degree. They interact with the rest of the universe through their environment suits which allow them to make contact with non energy beings. They are the youngest of the Created people. They are gravity based rather than electromagnetic based like most life(though I am not sure what that means, it was just something I saw that was interesting when doing research). They gain energy from gravity...somehow...they communicate through light pulses and use those to control the suits. they were initially quite dependent on outsiders to create their contact suits that allow them to talk and interact with material beings.

Esiksina: Robot descendants of the elders. There name means First Born. One of the few who still have members who remember what the ancients were like. They worship the ancients as gods.Probably will add a little more to this.

Pallasi: Warrior race who focus on tactics and strategy, they see everything in terms of wins and losses, often seen as emotionless and cruel, they see themselves as pragmatic and focused. Emotions are for private experience, not for others to see. The follow a set of philosophies based around warfare and tactics, either Clauswitz, Jomini, or other more esoteric disciplines. They are not necessarily warlike or violent, they just view everything as a problem to be solved through the application of tactic and logistics.  

The Ashrl-Kral: A newcomer to the galaxy, they have less political power than the other sophonts by far. However they are the most warlike and vicious race yet encountered. Focused on external honor and personal glory. Those who seek to become Star Knights have become some of the greatest heroes in the order. Those who seek to dominate have become some of the worst villains in history. Descended from some sort of super predator, it is thought they may have been uplifted by an as yet unknown species.There is a rumor that they were uplifted by the Maggedon.

Mugg: Small, cute, and cuddly, the Mugg exist nearly everywhere. They are some of the premier negotiators, pilots, and traders in the galaxy. They also have a very strong sense of individuality and freedom so many have become Star Knights. Amphibious species, probably based off of seals or something like that. Graceful in the water, they are still fairly swift and skilled on land.

Elder Peoples
Humani: Their name is thought to mean the Children of Wrath and their deeds spread far beyond the time and place of their origin, a small planet called Dirt. Masters of biotech and materials sciences capable of making the great symbiotech weapons and armor. Also creators of the five master martial forms. Martial arts that stand as the standard to this day. Unlike the other warrior races in history the humans seemed to have a strong sense of empathy for their enemies. They have the uncanny ability to understand others and still be able to kill them. They even were known to actively kill each other for reasons beyond mere momentary passion.
The Kha-Li:  Energy beings. Masters of the mind and the energy that lies within. No one quite knows if they discovered and developed Ikhai abilities, or if they created Ikhai whole cloth as a tool and weapon. Much has been lost. Master Ikhai Users with technologies that could enhance Ikhai powers to do things impossible even for a master.
The Bashro: Masters of stealth and energy storage. The only race to ever make stealth star ships work, no one knows how they did it. Almost nothing is known of them save for their name. Their are always rumors that the Bashro survived and live in hidden exile somewhere out in the back of beyond.


So there are the basics of the Intelligent species of the Galaxy and a brief bit about the history. What do you think? Am I right in going the direction I am going, or is there a better way? Maybe I am way off, let me know.

Challenge Of the Star Knights: The Breath Of Eternity

Before the Fourth Extinction War was a time of unprecedented growth and advancement in the universe. The Elders, now long gone, created wonders beyond imagining and their understanding of the universe stretched the very notion of what was possible. One such discovery was Ikhai, the Breath of Eternity. To many it seemed a perfect combination of the Known and the Unknowable, the Sublime channeled through the mundane technology. None now know whether the Elders grafted the ability to channel Ikhai into the younger peoples, or if it was somehow innate within all life, but to this day Ikhai is a powerful tool and a weapon against the forces of the Unmaker.

I was originally going to focus this post on creating Sophonts and history as well as digging a bit into technology and how that will work in the game. I still plan on doing that post, so no worries in that regard. However as I was working on that I started having a lot of different thought on how to make Ikhai work and how that would work in the setting. So this post is going to focus on the metaphysical and supernatural mechanics and abilities of the game. Many of the influences I mentioned in the first post have supernatural power of one sort or another. Mass Effect has biotics(as well as some sort of telepathy), Hunter x Hunter has nen abilities, Harry Potter has magic, Star Wars has the force, and the Legion of Superheroes has full on super powers. So when setting out to do my version of mystic abilities in space, I needed to focus a bit on what feel I was trying to go for. Did I want a more mystical feel, like in star wars, or a more formulaic and well defined route like in Harry Potter? When I started this I was unsure the route I wanted to go, but as I dug into the mechanics I started to see the direction that would work best for me.

When I started to look at the mechanical aspects of the game(here and here) I had only the very roughest of ideas on how I wanted Ikhai to work. I wanted cool powers like in Star Wars and such, so I put a line in the pitch about having cool powers and techniques that allowed one to be awesome. I didn't have a firm sense of how awesome or what that might mean.

Usually when I approach a project like this I start with the world and work toward mechanics. In this case I had already set out to make a game that fit within the D6 System paradigm and so I had a solid mechanical foundation to start from. In looking at the mechanics and the possibilities within it I saw some of the edges of the game and how I could use that to help me deal with my world building problem.  So in this case I started with the mechanics and built the world out from there.

First I needed to nail down some ideas for using Ikhai in game. I started with D6 Space as that seemed like a very good place to tart when dealing with science fantasy space opera. From there I moved outward and came up with a number of different ways I might go when doing these sorts of powers.

Method One: Use the standard Metaphysics rules as they exist. The system is workable as is, however it has a couple of problems I do not care for. The first problem is the complexity of using Metaphysics powers. It is too difficult to easily do it on the fly, and the complexity seems to serve no purpose other than to exist on its own. The second problem is, in my opinion, much more difficult. Metaphysics is hard to be good at early on, and so is kind of useless. However later on it takes on a primacy in play and anyone without it cannot seem to match a dedicated Metaphysics practitioner. That second one won"t be a huge issue in my game as the assumption is that everyone will have Ikhai abilities and so will have equal ability to do cool supernatural stuff. It is something to keep in mind though.

Method Two: Every skill has powers built into it. Basically what I would do is take the existing power building rules for metaphysics and apply it to every skill. This would allow for a lot of flexibility and a lot of interesting builds. you could have two people with identical skills have very different feeling characters in play. However this does have a major downside. It would ramp up the complexity of the game significantly. I am not sure if that would be worth the end result, It also could cause major indecision in the players when making a character as they would have so many options available to them.

Method Three: Rather than dedicating a new set of rules for the Ikhai abilities I could use this solution I found on +Raymond McVay's website .  Using this method there are no powers laid out in the mechanics specifically. Instead you use force/hero/fate points to indicate use of powers. Basically anytime you want to something crazy you spend a point and double your pool in an existing pool. The hard part would be increasing the difficulty level to an appropriate amount in order use a skill to do the impossible. How difficult should it be to walk up walls or jump over eighty feet? This would require a fair but of testing and such, but I do like its simplicity. It also allows the powers to fit what the table wants rather than what some unknown writer wants. You can ask the players to define the power and its limits. This one is what led me to the direction I am currently leaning which is...

Method Four: In this method you roll your Ikhai skill at the beginning of a scene in which you intend to use the abilities. From that roll you gain a number of points(probably a set number and you gain extra for every three you gain above the difficulty). These points can only be spent during the scene in which you rolled for them. You spend these points on enhancing actions beyond what is possible. You may spend more than one point per action if you want(though there may be a cost for doing that, I haven't quite decided yet.  You spend the points one for one on any of the following enhancements: No Tools(lets you create tools out of soul stuff), Increase Scale(which could let a normal person attack a on a star ship scale or greater), Use at a range(point blank, close, far, extreme), or adding dice to a roll(these do not count toward XP like character points). I figure there might be more uses you could put these to, but I think that is a solid start.

By and large, when looking through these options I really like method four, however I could see some problems with it. I would love to hear any thoughts on how to improve on it, or if I should try and use one of the other methods, or even another method entirely I have not thought of.

Challenge of the Star Knights: Ruminating on Rules Part 2

Part 1: The pitch
Part 2: Rules discussion part 1

There was only supposed to be one post on the rules mods I would be looking into for my game, However when writing up the last post I finding or inventing so many interesting ideas that I decided to split the post in two. In this one I will be delving a bit further in to rules mods and trying to explain my mindset a bit as I go through my options and choices. Lets get started, yeah?

Attributes and Skills
I could just go with one of the standard groupings of attributes and skills used in the various iterations of the D6 system throughout its long history. In looking through them, I found that I did not care for how they break down so much and I feel the need to work on a set of attributes that will fit my game a bit closer than the current sets do.

I ran across this post from the Walking Mind, and it is a fascinating look at how attributes are chosen and what that can mean for your game. I want to keep the number of attributes manageable, so I want less than seven, however I am not sure that three or four would do enough for what I want. I wan a game of rollicking space adventure focused around a group of students coming together to save the galaxy, or at least their section of it. Social stuff will be very important in that kind of game gaining and losing influence, the ability to work well together, and building networks of friends, rivals, and enemies all seem important. However at its heart the game is about playing Star Knights, so I think that there would be a lot of physical obstacles and confrontations as well. Though it is a school setting, I really don't see a need for a boat load of mental skills, as that is not really core to any activities they will be doing...maybe. So I think the breakdown on attributes that I want is two social attributes, three physical, and one mental. SO here are the ideas I have for the list:

Physical: Strength, Speed, Endurance(will probably change all of these names, but this gives me a solid starting point)
Social: Social Awareness, social control(less sure on these ideas)
Mental: Education(any Traveller fans out there?)

That is my current thinking on attributes, now to skills. Skills are both easier and harder for me. On the one hand I could just use them as they exist in the system and I know that will work. However I have had a few thoughts on this for a couple of different options for skills rather than just using the existing method.

Option 1: Don't have set skills but instead use something a little more freeform, like backgrounds. When a background would be useful in a situation add its level to the attribute dice for a roll and there you go. I am not sure I like this method, but it could lead to a lot of interesting stuff. I thought it worth mentioning.

Option 2: Instead of skill dice, you just have a rating with the skill which alters the difficulty(either subtracts from the difficulty number, or reduces the opponents die pool) of the roll. Again not sure if I like this, but it is interesting and would alter the way in which people look at the game...maybe.

Option 3: You have a maximum skill level(three or four dice) and you skills can never go beyond that. This is just a way to get around that huge dice pool people have mentioned many many times. Not sure I like this either.

Point of fact I am leaning toward a standard skill list with this game, though I will definitely be altering what skills are in the list and all that. I want the skills to feel more futuristic and also more school oriented. So any ideas on how to make that work by renaming existing skills would be appreciated.

The Basic Sketch on Ikhai Powers
This is currently very sketchy as I have a couple of different ways I could go with this and I am not really sure which is best or if I want to do any of the ideas I have had yet. My current thoughts are:

1. You have an Ikhai attribute with 4 skills however you choose one skill as your primary two as your secondary and the third is your opposition. Primary  skills cost the normal amount to advance and master. Secondary cost twice that to advance. And your opposition skill costs quadruple to advance.
Reinforce/buildup
Sense/hide energy/minds/thoughts
Manipulate objects
Create energy constructs

2. Your Ikhai abilities are an add on to existing skills and allow those skills to be temporarily boosted beyond what is possible. This is more nebulous even that the previous one as I am less certain how this would work other than increasing the scale in which that skill operates and maybe using skills without the needed tools...though that could get weird with stuff like vehicle operation...

I would love any thoughts on how to implement this as I think this particular facet of the game will be my biggest hurdle.

Vehicles
In standard D6 there is a bit of an issue with vehicles. The maneuver rating is added to the pilot's skill roll for dodging fire. By itself this is not such a huge issue, however it can lead to a massive disparity between the attackers roll and the defender's roll as the attacker does not get the same kind of equipment bonus. I have a solution to this that should work(I think).

When under attack you compare the maneuver ratings for each vehicle. If the defending vehicle has a higher rating then it gains a bonus d6 on the roll. If it has a lower rating then it has a penalty -d6 on the roll. That should reduce the number of dice added and all the odd results that follow while still allowing for maneuver ratings to matter.

Damage and Consequences
With  the D6 system there are currently two methods of handling damage, that I am aware of. Body Points and Wound Levels. After playing with them for a while I really dislike body points. They just feel off to me, and so I will be sticking with Wound Levels. Though I will be making some modifications to how damage works.

One of the issues that comes up with the wound system is that high strength characters can soak most damage, especially if they are wearing armor. I have a couple of thoughts on how to handle that:

1. When attacking  an opponent every die that is rolled that would be beyond what is needed to hit are added to the raw damage. So if you have four dice for attack and you need a twelve to hit; if three of your dice cover that 12 difficulty, your fourth die would be added to damage.

2. At the beginning of the attack action players may divide their dice pool into "to hit" pools, and "added damage pools", i.e. A character with 6d in Blasters can roll all six dice to hit, 4 dice to hit and add 2 dice to damage, or any variation of those 6 dice. The decision to divvy up between the two pools, gives it more of a tactical consideration.

3. This idea is a little further out there: Steal from Mouseguard and have a set of conditions that a character can mark rather than taking damage. This is kind of nebulous at the moment, but I think there is something to be said for it. It might also allow for social conflicts to have a little more tactical weight without having to construct a whole system for them.

Some Ideas that just didn't fit anywhere else
I had a couple of random ideas that I thought might be worth discussing, but didn't really seem to fit anywhere else so I will put them here.

If I wanted to add in something like Body Points, but I still wanted to avoid them on a systemic level I could add in force fields, like from Dune. Your force field can absorb a certain amount of hits and then it shuts down. I could even have a mystic Ikhai power that does a similar thing so that users of that could spend a turn making themselves tougher. Just a thought, and I will probably not use it. As soon as I did every Player Character would want to get a force field or that power, and the game would rapidly begin to revolve around that. Though perhaps the force fields shunt the damage into the environment and so cause hazards and problems for the heroes? As I said, just a thought that occurred to me.

I would like language and culture familiarity to be handled differently than skills. Perhaps a three tier system that lets you pick up familiarity rather quickly. You would spend CPs on it during the session. You may spend them(one per session) to gain the benefits of it in the moment. Once you have done that for three sessions(or something) you gain familiarity. And if you keep focusing on it like that you can eventually go native. Mind you, his would only be for games where people cared about different languages. Most gaming groups would not, and in fact that would be seen as a useless time sink.

A crazy idea: Seriously this is a crazy idea. I most likely won't use it, but it occurred and wanted to share it. So, if I choose to go with roll dice count successes(rather than normal roll dice add them up) I could do something like this: When you have increased your dice pool to ten(or whatever arbitrary number) rather than increasing it further you your skill drops back to 1d but your threshold for success goes up. So instead of a success on a 4+ you no get a success on a 3+. this would keep the dice pools lover and add in a sense of master(like in Heroquest/wars and Burning Wheel). Just a thought.

And that is the end of m first pass through the rules and the changes I will be making(or might be making) to the game. I would love to hear your thoughts on the matter as I am still on the fence on a number fo issues. Comments, critiques, and ideas are always welcome. That is it for mechanics for the moment. The next post will be a bit more on the universe the star knights inhabit and how I see that. Sounds like fun.