Trek to the Stars pt 5: Keys and Secrets

Since last post I dealt with the setting, I figured that this post I would delve a bit further into the mechanics of the thing. Since I first heard about them, keys have fascinated me. It changed the way I looked at much of game design. Such a simple thing to have such a powerful effect. I found that merely adding keys to an existing game changed the state of play on a fundamental level.

I have also made a decision about the nature of skills. In a previous post I set down two separate thoughts on how to do roll and keep in the game. In this post I will go into the decision I made and how I see it playing out.

Should you wish to look through the previous posts related to this project, here they are:
The original idea for a system
Part 1 where I talk about my influences and a loose brainstorm for the setting
Part 2 where I put down the basics of dice rolling and the initial skill list
Part 3 where I discuss some ideas for potential campaign frameworks
Part 4 where I start giving some specifics of the setting

Keys
Keys are motivations, desires, problems, relationships, loyalties, and duties that cause your character to act. In a way they are a bit like aspects in Fate. They drive you to take action and grant you a reward for taking that action. In Shadow of Yesterday the bonus they get is experience points, in Fate the bonus is fate points. In Trek to the Stars they serve both functions. You gain character points by following your keys, and then you gain experience points when you spend character points on taking action.

The issue I have always had with Keys is the difficulty I have with constructing them. When you see a good Key, you know that it is indeed good. When you get a bad one though, or a mediocre one, you can feel it is bad, but not necessarily what went wrong with it. In this I will lay out the basics of Keys as it was set down in Shadow of Yesterday. In future posts I will try my best to set out some really solid examples(fingers crossed). Keep in mind that the numbers might change as we move forward in this project.

From original document
Keys are the motivations, problems, connections, duties, and loyalties that pull on your character. To the player, they're highly important because they generate experience points. Creating new Keys may be easier than new Abilities or Secrets - they follow very simple rules.

• A Key must involve a motivation, problem, connection, duty, or loyalty.

• Keys come in two types: * Motivations. When the motivation is fulfilled in play, gain an experience point. When the motivation is fulfilled against good odds, gain three experience points. * Everything else. When the Key comes up in play, gain an experience point. When the Key presents a minor problem, gain two experience points. When it presents a major problem, gain five experience points.

• All Keys have a Buyoff, which is a reversal from the Key by the character. All Buyoffs give the character 10 experience points. This Buyoff occurs only when you, the player, wants it to happen: you can lose a battle with the Secret of Bloodlust and still keep the Secret. If you want your character to undergo a change in his personality, though, adding to the story, you can take this Buyoff by fulfilling it. If you do take the Buyoff, you can never take this Key again.

So that is the basics of Keys. I will be designing them along those lines, though I will definitely be manipulating the numbers. I see folks earning character points two ways for each Key. You gain one point when it comes up in play, and five points(ten points?) when you resolve it. It is generally resolution that I find most difficult to nail down. So any advice on Keys and how I should use them in this game would be greatly appreciated.

Secrets
I am rather fond of this name for a special ability within a skill. I had been vacillating between perk and technique for that name. Then I reread Shadow of Yesterday and saw secret. Such a fine name. It reminds me of the old classic Shaw Brothers films, everyone is all the time learning secrets of their given skill. Each skill has a number of secrets attached to it secrets can do a number of things. What follows are the rules for constructing secrets for the skills. I will probably build a bunch when I go back through and do a finishing run on the skill list.

• Allow you to keep an extra die on a given roll(usually only in a given circumstance)
• Give you a minor unique ability of some sort or permission to use your skill in a new way
• Increase the scale of the skill in a specific circumstance 
• Increase effect or damage of a skill after the roll

I think that will cover a lot of ground for secrets, though I would love to hear any ideas on ways to expand this list. I also need to sort out my skill list and how I would like to describe the skills. As they are important I am leaning toward giving each skill a larger description than they might normally get. I am currently trying to work through the skill list and make it work. I am trying to figure out knowledge skills and language/culture skills as I think they would be useful and interesting. That said, I am uncertain how best to use them in my game. Any thoughts on those would also be appreciated.

My next post will be on the future history, giving a nice long view of how the next couple centuries will go(in my setting at least, I am no Nostradamus). I will also talk about the uplifts, gene mods, cyborgs, and my problems with AI. Alright that is it for this post, let me know what you think. Comments, critiques, and suggestions are always welcome.

Trek to the Stars part 4: Future History and Advanced Technology

H'okay so today I will be working on the setting a bit more and laying down some possibilities of the setting. I have these thoughts rolling around in my head, they are not really coalescing though. I will lay out what I have and hopefully spur some discussion on what to do with them. This is all just kind of roughing out the setting and building a solid base for future developement. If you have any thoughts, please let me know.If you would like to look at what I have already worked out on for the game(system and setting) here are the links.
The initial Idea
Part 1 My influences and some thoughts on what I would like to see
Part 2 A tentative skill list and a fleshing out of the die mechanic
Part 3 My thoughts on campaign frameworks that fit within the setting and system

That out of the way, here goes. My ideas for the setting of Trek to the Stars:

Future History
350 years in the future, after the world fell and the sky opened up again, we have moved beyond our small blue sphere and have taken our place in the heavens.  Mars terraforming is nearing the end of phase two. Venus is going a different route. The game is set in the year 2365, and the frontiers of Man are limitless.

Mercury is split between two nations, several mining firms, the unions, and the independent miners trying to make a living. 

Venus has a great many cities in the sky(as oxygen is a lifting gas there) they harvest the gene modded plants that float in, and live off, the vast cloud cover while dispersing vast amounts of ice into the planetary atmosphere. These shining cities drift on the winds and help deflect some of the solar rays that bombard the planet.

On and around Earth the old nation states still cling to their power and history, though many new nations have risen. This is the heart of the old Lords of the System(basically the aristocracy that has lost much power lately, but still holds more influence than some would like). This is a hotbed of politics and money, as well as extreme political leanings. With so many folk leaving the planet the populations have been lowered significantly. 

Luna was once heavily populated, though now many folk have moved out to the new colonies and wide open spaces. Now it sits as backwater and historical site. Like a ghost town, but in space.

Mars has enough atmosphere that folks can breath unaided, and there are even some rivers and lakes. It is separated into three(or more, haven't decided yet) nations. There was a recent civil war has concluded over the southern portions of the planet, They seceded from, and were retaken by, a large neo-fascist regime. Their luxuries and education are currently being taxed punitively by their fascist overlords.

Ceres exists as the trade hub of much of the asteroid belt. Anything can be bought and traded here. It stands neutral in the dealings of the solar system at large. A great many asteroids have been moved near it so that miners can trade easier.

Europa has vast cities hanging from the ice down into the unlit depths. They have little to do with the outside system, the only access to their undersea realm is two surface stations over great elevators to the subsurface populations.  The remaining Jovian moons are also heavily colonized, though I still haven't worked out how it is all arranged.

The moons of Saturn are home to a pseudo-feudal society that controlled most trade of He^3 throughout the system. They are a rich and jealous of others power. They live lives of glorified violence as one of the only ways to advance beyond the serf/peasant/worker caste is to join the local military and distinguish yourself. Distinguished soldiers can be adopted into the ruling families. Military might and economic power are all that matter on the grand scheme. Each lord serves a higher lord and so on. All fall under the domain of the Saturn Emperor.

The independents around Uranus have begun to cut into the Saturn Baronies profits with their cheaper and easier to extract He^3. They are a disorganized and unruly bunch. Libertarian ideals founded the colonies, but soon thereafter the society almost collapsed and so a slightly stronger government was constructed, but the people are still independent and free wheeling.

Out beyond this lies the great frontier. The moons of Neptune, Pluto, the Kuiper belt, and Eris are all somewhat colonized. Many hermits, tribes, bands, micro-nations, and families have moved out to the region with nothing but a fusion plant, a ship, and a fabricator. Live is hard, but riches can be had with a bit of work and a bit of luck.

Major Important Technologies
Fusion Reactors: Invented in the mid twenty-first century its proliferation changed everything. Requires He^3 or Deuterium as fuel, depending on the model of reactor. A small one can power a habitat large enough for six for years with little complex maintenance.

Fabricators: A large machine that uses robotics and micro-robotics to construct anything it has the plans for. You must put the required material in the required amounts into the hopper. No household should be without one. You must purchase fabrication rights for the plans of any item you wish to construct and raw materials needed. Pirated plans and hacked fabricators are difficult to obtain, but not impossible. Laws regarding rights usage often change depending on which country you are in and from which the plans come. Basically advanced versions of 3D Printers.

Solar Sails: The cheep method of traveling (relatively)swiftly throughout the system. Solar sails are the preferred method for most colonists.

Ion Thruster: Using argon this engine provides steady thrust at a low cost. I am unsure if there isn't a better drive than this one, I do love the name of it though.

Mass Driver: An electromagnetic accelerator used to transport goods from ground to orbit. Used on Mercury, Luna, and several of the moons of the gas giants.

Alcubierre Shunt: A device like a beacon that allows a ship to travel faster than light for short periods. It bends space into a warp bubble around your ship and then fires that bubble of in a direction. In order to end the effect you must strike another beacon. Travel can take anywhere from a week(Earth to Venus) to a month and a half(Earth to Neptune)

Space Elevators: Mars and Titan have the only currently operational space elevators in the system. Though Earth has been working on constructing one for the last two years.

Vacuum Balloon: Recently materials science has advanced enough that this has become a possibility. Now there are several Vacuum Airships patrolling the skies of Venus. And recently a few such airships have been sent to Jupiter as a proof of concept toward building permanent cities in Jupiter's upper atmosphere.

Trek to the Stars Part 3: But what do they actually do?

I have been working on a new project for a little while now(her is Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3), and I have been enjoying working through the ramifications of the rules and setting so far. I am now at the point where I need to start narrowing the field of play. Those who know anything about my design philosophy know that I am firm believer that play should be focused around a central conflict or theme. At heart I am always asking myself, "what do the player characters do in the game?" and, "how do the games rules help encourage that behavior?"

After I set out the mechanical basics of the game, in the last post, I got into a bit of a discussion about the emergent properties of play. During the discussion I came to a few conclusions about the setting and system. The system is heavily focused on choice(in the dice you choose to keep) and precision(you crit upon getting the exact target number). The system also focuses on pushing yourself beyond the normal limits(you can increase the difficulty to gain extra effect and you can spend character points to increase your number of rolled or kept dice) and seeking to do the impossible(failure grants bigger XP rewards than success). The way XP works also tends to lead to player proactivity and focus on choice(the only way to improve a skill is to find a legitimate use for the skill).

The setting, what there is of it, also has some implications. In discussing it, I realized that there were a couple of themes and genres running through the potential setting. There is big frontier feel to the setting so far. Humanity has spread beyond earth and have settled all throughout the solar system. This seems to indicate that in general populations of places will be lower per square mile than current populations. Also there are the ideas of exploration and expansion, with travel being somewhat slow and people living in the Kuiper belt and all. The expansion of the human form and ideas about what it means to be human(or sapient) leads to another area for expansion, exploration, and defining the frontier.  So I see several possible campaign frameworks that would work within  this setting(as it stands). I found this thread on rpg.net to be of much use in working out some basic campaign ides.

Potential campaign ideas:

1. You play as frontiersmen who must stand between barbarity and civilization. I see this as anywhere from The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance to The Magnificent Seven, but in space. The focus would be on the nature of using force to protect the innocent. I could see things on the Martian frontier going this route, the miners on Mercury would also be a fine place for it, as could the tiny colonies out past Pluto. 
2. A game where you play roving lawmen who deliver mail and justice. Think of it as Dogs in the Vineyard throughout the solar system, or like the second half of Tombstone where Wyatt Earp is hunting down Cowboys with fiery vengeance. You could play as members of a federal law enforcement service keeping the peace throughout the state, or as members of something like Interpol, but for the whole solar system. You would spend most of the game hunting fugitives, terrorists, and smugglers.
3. the political game, where you are back in civilization and dealing with the players and movers and shakers. Whether it is the Genetically Enhanced rulers of the Saturn Baronies or the infighting within the libertarian Free Republic of Rand(still working on names), the idea of this game is to play the elite in their fight for control of power and influence. It is very Dune-esque in my mind. 
4. Rebels still fighting the last war after it has been over for five years or more. I am unsure as to what the war was about, but my view of the setting as a western requires some sort of war to have ended recently. Basically during the war a number of states established a stronger power base and subsumed several smaller nations and rebel states. In this you would play the remnants of the armies that fought in the war. You may have lost nearly everything, but you still have your pride and your will not give up.
5. You play settlers/miners out on the fringe, this would be mostly about dealing with a small community and the struggles of making a living on the edge of livability. The game would focus in interpersonal problems and dealing with unexpected problems. External threats would be meteor collisions, radiation leaks, bandits/pirates, and machinery failure. 
6. Traders/performers/travelling scrap collectors and repair men(for big stuff that is hard for folks to repair on their own) travelling the routes across the solar system would be pretty fun as well. You would travel from place to place trying to make a living through your skills and wits. 
7. Missionaries or travelling priests ministering to the masses throughout the system. I think this would be an interesting one to work with. Again it would be a bit like Dogs in the Vineyard, though with less shooting.  This is a campaign type that I have not seen much of in many games, so working on this would be kind of cutting a new path. That does appeal. Also it would allow for some interesting conflicts related to religion and its role in civilization.
8. The love boat in space, seriously, think about it. It would be an awesome game. 
9. Planetary surveyors on a mission to detail the lands and resources of a region, I think it would be neat to play interplanetary Luis and Clark. I have some ideas on how I would do it as well, so that is a thing. 
10. Artifact investigation and recovery teams. After the last war there were many historical artifacts missing after raids and pillaging. Think The Monument's Men but in space. 
11. Journalists seeking to get the scoop on various big incidents is another type of campaign you don't see all that much in games(or at least, I haven't seen it much). I am unsure how to go about doing it, but it would be a neat campaign framework, or at least a solid character concept.

So those are the basic campaign ideas I had for this project. What do you think? Is there an area you see that I didn't cover? Are there some ideas that you think would just be terrible in practice? I would love to hear your thoughts, comments, and concerns.

Trek to the Stars: Beginnings part 2

In the last couple of posts I have written about the beginnings of some game ideas I have been tinkering with. The idea is kind of stuck in my head, and I am working through the basic ideas to alleviate this issue. If you are interested, here are links to the earlier posts:
The Beginnings of a Mechanical Idea
Part 1: setting basics

In this post I will be digging a bit further into the mechanics. Last time I talked about the basics of how the skills and die rolls will work, but it was all in generic terms. This time I would like to nail down some of the specifics of the system. I have a couple of ideas on how to do skills and I would like to discuss the possibility of both before making a decision. In fact I think I might be able to combine both, but lets get into it before I go further with ideas I have not described yet.

Both ideas work on the same basic idea. For each skill you roll a pool of six sided dice and then you can select a number of them to keep and try and overcome a target number. The target number is set by the GM, but you can increase it to add an effect to the roll(still working on the specifics of this). If you hit the exact target number that counts as a critical success(still working on what that means). The dice pool cannot go over ten(I have found that a dice pool of over ten dice tends to get unwieldy). As I am using d6s for this I feel like using the skill list(or at least some of the skill list) from the d6 System. So here it is.

Potential skill list
Acrobatics: Dodging, jumping, climbing, and maneuvering
Close Combat: Hand to hand with fists, kicks, weapons, and all things in between
Ranged Combat: Shooting and throwing in a fight over distance
Flying/0-G: Use for athletics and acrobatics in a zero g environment, or when flying(if you can fly)
Athletics: Swim, Run, lift
Navigation: Figuring out where you are, and how to get where you want to go
Pilot/ride: Controlling vehicles and riding beasts(maybe I should have two skills?)
Computer/communications: Using computers and communications gear
Sensors: Operating sensor systems(maybe combine with computers?)
Heavy Weapons: Using indirect fire weapons and vehicle weapons
Knowledge/wise/knowing stuff: This is a bunch of skills and I need to work out what should apply and how it should apply. I kind of want to do it like Burning wheel's wises.
Language/culture: This is important, but I am uncertain how to make it interesting without making the game about this.
Willpower: Strength of will
Craft: Making things
Perception: Noticing and investigating
Stealth/pickpocket/burglary: maybe more than one skill for all the underhanded and subtle skills
Persuade: Using emotional appeal
Bargain: Using material leverage(money, goods)
Con: Using false authority
Repair: fixing and diagnosing things
Medicine: Diagnosing and fixing people
Demolitions: Energetically deconstructing things on the macro scale

So that is the current list of skills I have. I am still on the fence on some of them and missing chunks of skills that need further extrapolation. I would love suggestions and any thoughts on this section.

Now to get to the two ideas I had.

Idea 1: Approaches
In Fate Accelerated there are no skills or attribute. There are approaches which describe how one goes about doing things rather than what one can do. The approaches are: Careful, Clever, Flashy, Forceful, Quick, and Sneaky. In this idea You roll a number of dice equal to your skill rating and keep a number of dice equal to the approach you are using for the skill. Any skill can be paired with any approach, based on how you describe the action.

Example time: You are in a running firefight with a group of bandits on a farmstead near Tharsis. You have a ranged combat rating of 6 and are trying to draw there fire. You have a flashy rating of 2. The difficulty to hit the bandit is 7. You roll six dice and get 4, 3, 5, 2, 2, 1. You must pick three of those and add them together to try and get over the target number. You take the 2, 2, and the three. This is a critical success. You do double damage(or whatever we end up letting critical success mean). You win this round and the game move forward.

I see this being interesting, but a bit fiddly. It does allow for giving in game actions an extra level of meaning and import. However, if I go this route, the approaches would need to top out at something like five or six. Any more and things get really complicated.

Idea 2: Level Based Perks
Another idea, rather than using approaches you have a series of perks or whatever. These are similar to Alternity's skill rank benefits. So you need a certain skill level and then can spend points to gain the benefit out of your skill xp that you have already placed into the skill. In this system you should start with the ability to only keep two dice per roll and then the rank benefits allow you to increase that, as well as removing penalties and allowing for normally impossible actions.

So that is my idea. I am currently leaning toward Idea 2, as it allows for more control and will help spread the skill xp around a bit once you have spent your character points. I could combine the two ideas and really get finicky, but I am unsure if that would work all that well. I would love to hear your thoughts, critiques, and suggestions.

Trek to the Stars: a begining

In my last post I put forth the skeleton of a game system that I thought was interesting. I want to manipulate this system and build something lasting out of it. In order for me to do that, I must build(or use) a setting to place within that system. While some designers can work on a system in a vacuum, I am just not wired that way. For me, I need fiction to give the mechanical system emotional meaning.

Keeping that in mind I need to start building a setting for the system. Possibly I should also come up with a title for the project. My first urge is to do a science fiction setting. I really love science fiction, no big surprise if you have watched the games I have run. I love engineering and science and I try and keep up on new technologies and new ideas for technologies. So I kind of decided on science fiction, but what type?

I asked around a bit and got back an answer of cyberpunk in a colonized Sol system. I dug parts of that, so I decided to use bits of it. I have already done my take on cyberpunk with the game Jadepunk. So I decided to go another way. I would do a solar system space game with some cyberpunk and some not. I find that what helps me design a game is to get down a list of influences and things I would like to see in the game, so here goes:

Influences

• Star Trek: I am and have always been a fan of Star Trek. Next Generation was my first connection with science fiction and throughout my teenage years it was one of the few science fiction shows that showed me an optimistic future.
• Dune: I love the high action mixed with high politics. I love the setting details and how the environment effects everything within. The book is just fun.
• Farscape: I love this show, it is the best version of Buck Rogers ever filmed. Folks who are accidentally both awesome and helpless. It was never afraid to take risks and they let the story go where it needed to. Overall, one of the best science fiction shows of the last fifty years.
• Transhuman Space: The setting that got me to buy GURPS, it even got me to play GURPS, and GURPS is not the kind of game I really enjoy. This setting was so deep and interesting and also so connected to the GURPS mechanics that it made everything come together into a mighty fine game.
• Ben Bova's Grand Tour series: I really love these books, despite that they can sometimes get a bit preachy(Venus I am looking at you). The science is fun, the characters are interesting and much of the conflict is the conflict of personalities. 

With those influences lets see what I can come up with for a setting pitch. Each planet, dwarf planet, and asteroid of appropriate size has been colonized to some extent. Many of them have been terraformed and support there own offshoots of humanity. I am a fan of hard(ish) science fiction, but I am also a fan of the softer science fictions, so I want soft science fiction(it is easier to be loose with physics from a setting design standpoint) with a heavy dose of hard science fiction on the top. Basically I would expect to go with hard sci-fi except for a few areas of wonky tech that breaks the rules, but only in specific and controllable ways. Mostly where I will be making science soft is in the area of human augmentation, travel times between planets, and perhaps artificial gravity(perhaps, I am on the fence on how I want to do this). I want to avoid casual FTL(or FTL in general), though again I need some way to get from the earth to Pluto in less than a year. I love solar sails but they are slightly too slow for that. Maybe I will go with solar sails and then some sort of shunt that does short distance FTL, like a wormhole network that can only really work within a system, for reasons.

I already have some plans for the various planets. Mercury is a mining colony buried in the polar regions and orbiting in space stations. Venus is filled with cities in the clouds, aerostats of immense size launching genetically engineered plants and bacteria into the cloud layer while showering the planet with ice(for the hydrogen). Mars has an awesome space elevator. the asteroid belt has a bunch of tiny nations that are all seeking to control various economic interests. Jupiter and Saturn are a hive of activity, skimming He3 for fusion reactors and such. The further outreaches of the system are filled with nomads and hermits, people who wish to be left alone and explorers seeking new opportunities. I see a lot of political maneuvering and many small wars and conflicts. Its like the old west, where there is civilization, "back home," and there is the frontier where anything is possible, but the danger is greater.

I see humanity having multiple nations, worldviews, religions, and all that. I also see the future as introducing new ways of interacting with the world. Humanity will have three branches now: Baselines, Cyborgs, and Genetically Modified Humans(need a better name for each of these). Basically these would be three differing ways of looking at and dealing with problems. Baselines would look at a problem gather the right tools and then work at modifying the situation to suit there needs. Cyborgs would just alter their bodies to overcome the problem(sort of brute force through resleeving or modular design). Genetically modified humans would alter themselves and the environment through genetic engineering(basically they adapt to their environment). This all needs some deeper thought, for sure, but that is the basic idea.

 Humans will also have a few AIs and some uplifted species. True AIs will be rare as in my mind they would need both the correct hardware and software, and then they would need to be lucky. Sometimes the creation of AI doesn't work right, either there are serious emotional issues or the program self destruct as it nears sapience. I want there to be AIs, but I want them to be rare and special, and I want then to have limits like any being has. As for uplifts, I would love to come up with something really cool here, something that hasn't been done before but also something that makes sense. I am leaning toward Squid, Sea lions, Crows/pigeons, Raccoon, or parrots. I would love to hear any thoughts on which I should use, or if I should use them at all.

Alright so that sums up the bare bones of the setting. I would love to hear your thoughts on it. Specifically any areas of the setting that seem off or inconsistent. Also any areas that you are super exited about. Let me know what you think.

The beginings of a big idea

I have been busy these last couple...um, years I guess. What with Jadepunk and Iconic Adventures I have had significantly less time to write my own stuff. Not that I am complaining, I like having work, and I love my jobs. But I realized I have been sort of neglecting my blog. I also realized I have been focused almost entirely on Fate throughout the life of this blog. I love Fate, so that is not a surprise. That said, I have lots of other ideas that do not fit directly into the Fate mind space. Here is my idea(s) I would like to update the blog more often than I have been, at least once a week would be good. I would also like to expand into some of my non-Fate ideas. I will still probably work quite a bit with Fate, but I do have other loves and other ideas, so I will try and put some more of those out as well. All that in mind here is an idea I have had that I think has some legs on it.

The idea started with my love of WEG Star Wars and my distaste for a specific mechanic within it. That mechanic carried forward throughout all of the D6 System that followed. The problem was Character Points. Here is the basics of how that works. You do adventures and all the stuff, yeah? And then you get character points which you can spend to increase skills and abilities. So far sounds like a different name for XP, yeah? Well here is where it falls apart. You can also use your character points as a momentary increase in a skill, one point will add a die to a roll. The issue is that there is no reason to ever do this. Your gains in the short term will make you inferior to others in the long term. And the more you spend the worse it gets. So how to fix it?

Well I was involved in a conversation a while back where the merits of the D6 System were being discussed. I can't currently find a link to the discussion, but in it we got to talking about the problem with character points. I believe it was +Bruce Baugh(and please correct me if I am wrong, or let me know if you have a link to the discussion) who said something that stuck with me. Basically the idea was that you only got to spend your character points on advancement after you had used them to enhance a roll. This concept BLEW MY MIND! Seriously I had this discussion months and months ago and yet it just kept rolling around in my mind. The repetitive and cyclic nature of my mind allowed for me to gather some other ideas I liked and mash them together. This is that idea.

The other ideas I liked were Keys from Shadow of Yesterday(and Lady Blackbird, also milestones from Marvel Heroic Roleplaying) and use based advancement from Burning Wheel.  Normally how I would go forward with this idea is to introduce one concept at a time over the course of a couple/three blog posts. I have found that can be problematic, though, as people sometime misconstrue what I am doing. Therefore in this post I am going to give the basic rundown of the system as a whole and then open it up for discussion.

We start with a dice pool system, what type does not matter all that much. I am partial to Roll/Keep style systems(like in 7th Sea or Legend of the Five Rings), though D6 System is open, so I may use that. It must have a fairly comprehensive skill list, and every skill would need to listed on the character sheet(maybe, I have a thought on this, but it is incomplete). Each skill rating would be done with filled in bubbles(like World of Darkness), with a series of empty boxes below it, one box beneath each circle. I do not think you need attributes or any false distinction like them. Just a big list of skills should work fine. I know there are more details to be worked out here, but for my purposes this works enough that I can move forward.

Every character will have a list of keys/milestones these are how they gather character points. I have not set out a specific number of them just yet, though my instinct is for there to be three. You will want enough that you will get at least two character points a session, but not so many that you can gain an overwhelming amount. I will be honest here, this is the part I added in last and so is still a bit muddy. I know that it fits and that it will work, I am just unclear on some of the specifics.

Character points sort of work like in the D6 System, you spend one point to increase a roll by one die. You can spend more than one point per roll, but you will never get more than one die per point. This can be done before or after a roll has landed. After your roll, win or lose, you mark a check box for each character point you spent on that roll. Once you have filled in enough check boxes your rating in the skill goes up. I have two thoughts on what should constitute enough check boxes. The first is to increase a skill rating when the check boxes marked off equal the current rating. The second is just to set it at some arbitrary number, like ten or something. Both ideas work, I think. I just am unsure which is the best for the game.

This allows for some interesting interactions. You gain character points through making decisions and adding drama. You spend those points to push your skills further than they should be capable gaining experience in that skill by using it in situations that are beyond your normal capabilities. It also allows for you to gain skill in in areas you know nothing about just by pushing yourself. Though that might be abusable, need to think on that.

Potential issue:
-gaining skill far too fast. I could see someone pushing character points at a single skill all the time and growing massively in only one or two areas. Another thought is the guy who spends all his character points on untrained skills and thus is kind of adequate at everything but sucks compared to anyone with real training. I am not really sure these are issues, but they are on my mind.

Another thought I had was to give only half the experience(rounded down) in a skill if you succeed at the task. This represents a personal view I have. My view is that you make greater leaps in learning through failure, whereas success grants smaller, incremental, growth. I am not sure if that would work. It might feel a bit like gambling and hoping to lose.

So there you have it. It is not all that complex, nor is it all that new an idea. I do think it warrants further discussion and so I would love to hear your thoughts on the matter. Let me know what you think.

FATEsy Heartbreaker: Stunt Trees and Magic Systems

I have been working on Heartbreaker now for more than a year and I had been stumped on how to do a few key items that failed to come together. First I really dislike the magic system I originally came up with. It works, it's serviceable, but it didn't really evoke the feel I was going for. Another issue I have been having is a method of building a mechanism for procedurally generating setting and history. I want there to be certain themes and elements of the setting without having to nail down every detail. This becomes problematic, but I believe I am getting closer to a solution on that end. My final issue is the name of the hack. Back when I started Heartbreaker worked, it was kind of funny and kind of close to what I was trying to do. Now that I am at something like 24 posts into Heartbreaker, the name doesn't really work anymore. There is a lesson in that, do not make light of naming things. You never know when it will come back to bite you in the butt.

Earlier today I was out walking, I do that sometimes to work through a problem, and I got to thinking about my magic system problem. I wanted a system that would work with the cosmology I had constructed earlier. It is a world of many gods, each with their own idea on how the world should work and what it should look like. The world that exists is a compromise between the the biggest and most powerful gods. The laws of physics operate as they do here on earth. Magic is the ability to circumvent that in some way. The gods use magic to alter the world to fit their needs. The drive their power from the great non-personifications, order and chaos, from which the gods sprang at the dawning of reality. Mortals cannot do magic without a great deal of help. They can draw their power from the gods or from order and chaos themselves.

That in mind, there are three forms of magic that can be learned/harnessed by mortals. Haake allows practitioners to control the very forces of order and chaos themselves to create temporary, but powerful, effects. It is the most difficult form of magic, but it is exceptionally versatile. Bargomen is the making of deals with spirits, gods, and powerful entities with the purpose of gaining information or a permanent magical boon. Deurgy is similar in some ways to Bargomen in that it allows for the channeling of godly magic. It is somewhat more flexible than Bargomen though less so than Haake. It involves making a deal with a specific spirit or god to gain a permanent power that can be refocused as desired, when one has the time. The downside to Deurgy is that you must follow the rules set down in the agreement, usually a set of taboos, though it can become something like a geis or curse. There are two other forms of magic, but they are a bit funky, so I thought to leave them off for the moment. They are items of power and supernal skill. I will work on them in a future post.

I think what I would like to do with the magic systems here is to use a modified version of Jadepunk's asset rules. Here are my initial thoughts:
Haake
You may spend one point of permanent refresh to gain the ability to create one temporary spell using the asset creation rules with intelligence as the key attribute. You may gain more spells by spending more refresh. You can only use these spells for one scene, all other rules apply. You cannot gain any of the other magical systems. They simply do not work on you anymore as you are meddling with the source magic. Digging deep into the underpinnings of creation itself.
Bargomen
To gain a godly boon you must make a bargain with a god or spirit. You use the asset creation rules utilizing Charisma as the key attribute. However once the bargain is struck you must spend permanent refresh to turn the created asset into a permanent asset. You may start the game with assets created in this way, though you must still make the rolls required. These are permanent spells etched into your soul and body. They may alter your perception or your body. There are those who have bargained away everything for power and have become monstrous and strange in the process.
Deurgy
Deurgy is a bit strange. The refresh cost is variable as you gain access to a power set or spell theme that is thematically linked to to the god or spirit that you channel. The power is fixed, but can be altered at any refresh scene(when you would gain back your refresh, generally the milestones, though it is possible to have a refresh scene without the milestone. You must take a taboo, geis, or curse aspect to represent your pact with the being. This must be one of your character aspects other than your high concept or trouble. Essentially this gives you a second trouble aspect. Should you go against the taboo aspect, your GM can compel the aspect to remove your power set or spell theme. The only way to get it back is to atone. Generally atonement will be a quest that brings glory or recognition to the god or spirit that grants the power.

Magic spells and powers can be created using any of the features of devices and techniques. Features unique to allies remain so. Finding gods and spirits is an adventure in and of itself. Gods and spirits are not omnipresent, nor are they fully omniscient. They exist in a singular place at any given time. However their power is based, to some degree, on how much control and how known they are throughout the world. This tends to mean that one can find spirits and gods if you do the right research or know the right folks.

So that is my initial take on the magic systems for Heartbreaker. What do you think? Also anyone have any thoughts on what I should rename this project?